What Is the Probate Process in New York?
The probate process in New York requires consideration of many statutes, rules and procedures. There have been many articles published in the New York Probate Lawyer Blog discussing the probate of a Will.
Fundamentally, a Will is a written document which contains provisions that set forth the manner by which a person wants an estate to be distributed. A Will speaks after a person dies. It has no effect prior to death.
The probating of a Will is the process by which a Court, typically a New York Surrogate’s Court, reviews and validates a Will. Once the document is validated it is deemed admitted to probate and a Decree Admitting a Will to Probate is issued by the Court. Usually, Letters Testamentary are then issued to the Executor. The Letters reflect the Executor’s appointment and authority to act as the estate representative.
Who Can Contest a Will in New York?
During a probate proceeding, a decedent’s next of kin (“distributees”) have a right to object to the probate. Essentially, if the Will is deemed invalid, the estate may be found to be subject to distribution according to the laws of intestacy. This means that the estate assets become distributable to the distributees instead of the beneficiaries named in the invalid Will.
At the outset of the Surrogate’s Court proceeding, a Citation, which is like a summons, will be issued to the distributees informing them of a date, time and place to appear in Court. On the Court return date, a distributee can advise the Court as to any Objections to Probate they wish to assert.
Thereafter, the parties have the right to engage in what are called discovery procedures whereby documents can be examined and the testimony of witnesses obtained. This discovery material is intended to demonstrate the validity of a Will. For instance, the testimony of the attorney who prepared a Will and supervised its execution can be taken along with the attesting witnesses. Medical and financial records of a decedent may be obtained. The discovery process allows a broad range of inquiry.
What Are the Most Common Grounds for Contesting a Will in New York?
At some point, distributees must decide whether they are actually going to file formal Objections to Probate. The most common Objections include lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence and that the documents were not properly executed.
Testamentary capacity and undue influence usually come to mind first and appear to be the most attractive responses to a Will which does not provide for distributions which Objectants may have expected. However, both testamentary capacity and undue influence are difficult to prove. Unless there are provable factual circumstances, it may be difficult to show that a decedent could not make a thoughtful independent decision about an estate plan at the time a Will was signed.
Can a Will Be Contested Because of Dementia or Incapacity?
The fact that a decedent was old or suffering from an illness including a malady such as dementia, does not automatically mean that a Will is invalid. Even a determination that a decedent was incapacitated and requires a Court appointed Article 81 Guardian does not prevent a person from executing a valid Will.
Can a Will Be Contested Because It Was Not Properly Executed?
Another ground for contesting a Will is that the document must be executed in accordance with the statutory requirements. Estates, Powers and Trusts Law Section 3-2.1 entitled “Execution and attestation of wills; formal requirements” provides the basic requirements for proper execution.
Sometimes the possibilities of using this section may be overlooked. For example, a testator must declare to the attesting witness that the document being signed is their Will. It is insufficient for the testator to say something like “please sign this paper.”
Recent Nassau County Probate Case: Will of Gloria M. Winslow
Obviously, the statutory framework and interpretation can be complicated. A recent Nassau County probate estate case entitled “Will of Gloria M. Winslow” decided by Surrogate David P. Sullivan on July 7, 2026, reflects this complexity.
In Winslow, one of the attesting witnesses was only 16 years old. After review the Court determined that while EPTL 3-2.1 mandated that a testator be at least 18 years of age, there is no required minimum age for an attesting witness. Ultimately, the Court admitted the Will to probate.
Why Is Experienced Legal Guidance Important When Contesting a Will?
As can be seen, the probate process and Objecting to a Will involves complex issues. Guidance from an experienced estate lawyer may be essential. I have been representing individuals in probate, estate and Guardianship cases for 40 years throughout New York City and all surrounding counties. Do you have a question regarding an estate or Guardianship? Call me now for a free confidential review of your issue. We provide reasonable and flexible fee arrangements and personal representation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Contesting a Will in New York
Who can contest a Will in New York?
During a probate proceeding, a decedent’s next of kin (“distributees”) have a right to object to the probate.
What are the most common grounds for contesting a Will?
The most common Objections include lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence and that the documents were not properly executed.
Can a Will be contested if the deceased person had dementia?
The fact that a decedent was old or suffering from an illness including a malady such as dementia, does not automatically mean that a Will is invalid.
What is the role of discovery in a New York Will contest?
The parties have the right to engage in what are called discovery procedures whereby documents can be examined and the testimony of witnesses obtained. Medical and financial records of a decedent may be obtained.
What are the requirements for properly executing a New York Will?
Estates, Powers and Trusts Law Section 3-2.1 entitled “Execution and attestation of wills; formal requirements” provides the basic requirements for proper execution.
Can a 16-year-old serve as an attesting witness to a New York Will?
In Will of Gloria M. Winslow, the Court determined that while EPTL 3-2.1 mandated that a testator be at least 18 years of age, there is no required minimum age for an attesting witness. Ultimately, the Court admitted the Will to probate.
Do You Have Questions Regarding an Estate or Guardianship?
Guidance from an experienced estate lawyer may be essential. I have been representing individuals in probate, estate and Guardianship cases for 40 years throughout New York City and all surrounding counties. Do you have a question regarding an estate or Guardianship? Call me now for a free confidential review of your issue. We provide reasonable and flexible fee arrangements and personal representation.
Contact New York Trusts and Estates Attorney Jules Martin Haas
New York Trusts and Estates Attorney Jules Martin Haas has helped many clients over the past 40 years resolve issues relating to guardianship and probate and estate settlement throughout New York City including Bronx, Queens, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Nassau and Suffolk Counties. Call (212) 355-2575 for an initial free consultation.
New York Probate Lawyer Blog


